David Welch Oak Bluffs

Martha’s Vineyard: A Complex History

Martha’s Vineyard, an island off the coast of Massachusetts, boasts a rich and multifaceted history that spans centuries. Its historical narrative is marked by various stages of development and societal changes.

Maritime Origins and the Slave Trade

In the late 17th century, Martha’s Vineyard began to emerge as a notable port for maritime activities, including the slave trade. Historical records reveal that the island played a role in the buying and selling of African individuals. Those who remained on the island after their enslavement typically served as house servants and agricultural laborers. This dark aspect of the island’s past is an important part of its historical record.

Emancipation and African-American Migration

Following the Emancipation Proclamation and the conclusion of the Civil War, many formerly enslaved individuals sought new opportunities. A significant number of freed slaves chose to relocate to Martha’s Vineyard, drawn by the prospects of employment in the island’s flourishing fishing industry. African-Americans from other parts of Massachusetts soon followed suit, establishing businesses to support the growing black population.

Oak Bluffs: A Historic African American Resort Community

Oak Bluffs, a town on Martha’s Vineyard, holds a unique place in history as one of several African-American summer resort communities founded in the 1890s along the Atlantic seaboard. The “Inkwell,” also known as Town Beach, became the favored destination for African Americans during this era, despite the derogatory nickname assigned by some white residents due to the beachgoers’ skin color. Over time, this pejorative term was reclaimed as a symbol of pride by the African-American community.

Religious Revival and Early Resort Growth

In the late 18th century, Methodist and Baptist revival meetings played a significant role in attracting both white and black visitors to Oak Bluffs. These early visitors were pivotal in stimulating the growth of the summer resort community. Land developers recognized the potential for profit as religious pilgrims and vacationers alike were drawn to the island’s scenic beauty, cooled by ocean breezes.

African American Property Ownership and Entrepreneurship

While racial discrimination and restrictive covenants persisted on the island, some early black servants became property owners, year-round residents, and small business entrepreneurs, particularly in Oak Bluffs. The legacy of their property ownership endures through their descendants. In the 1920s, African American Islanders began offering accommodations in their cottages, attracting visitors from cities such as Boston, New York, and Philadelphia.

Women Entrepreneurs and Shearer Cottage

A notable aspect of this history is the role played by women as entrepreneurs. Shearer Cottage, founded by Charles and Henrietta Shearer in 1912 as a summer inn, originally began as Henrietta’s laundry business in 1903. This cottage stands as one of the oldest and most renowned establishments catering specifically to African Americans. Multiple generations of the Shearer family have continued to manage the guesthouse into the 21st century.

Post-World War II Prosperity and Residential Growth

Following World War II, increasing prosperity within the African-American community led to more families vacationing in Oak Bluffs. Many of these vacationers became part-time or permanent residents, augmenting the island’s relatively small black population. The middle-class African-American vacationers of the 1950s through the early 1970s rented or purchased cottages at affordable prices. By 2010, the value of these properties had increased significantly, making Oak Bluffs arguably the wealthiest of the black resort communities.

Changing Demographics and Community Evolution

In recent years, workers from Brazil and Eastern European countries have replaced the African American service class on Martha’s Vineyard. The African-American leisure community that initially thrived in Oak Bluffs has expanded across the entire island, comprising a more extensive and diverse population. The community’s cohesion is now grounded in social activities, family connections, university affiliations, sorority and fraternity networks, as well as professional and business relationships.

Martha’s Vineyard’s history is marked by a complex interplay of cultural, economic, and societal shifts, with its African-American community playing an integral role in shaping the island’s rich tapestry of experiences and traditions.

After the Great fires in Martha Vineyard

The African-American community on Martha’s Vineyard, particularly in Oak Bluffs, faced significant challenges and changes over the years. While there was no single “Great Martha’s Vineyard Fire” that destroyed the African-American community, several factors contributed to shifts in the demographics and dynamics of the African-American population on the island.

One significant factor was changing property values and real estate trends. As the island became more popular as a vacation destination, property values increased. This, coupled with the limited availability of affordable housing, posed challenges for maintaining a year-round African-American presence.

Additionally, as Martha’s Vineyard became more accessible and attracted visitors from various backgrounds, the demographics of the island evolved. The African American population, once centered primarily in Oak Bluffs, began to disperse across different parts of the island.

While the African-American community in Oak Bluffs remains an important part of the island’s cultural heritage, it has transformed and adapted to these changing circumstances. Many families who were part of the historically African-American community on Martha’s Vineyard continue to have ties to the island, and the community’s legacy is celebrated and preserved. However, it’s important to note that there hasn’t been a single catastrophic event like a fire that wiped out the entire African-American community. Instead, demographic and economic changes have shaped the community’s evolution over time.

As of 2023, Martha’s Vineyard, an island located off the coast of Massachusetts, has a unique demographic profile, economy, and census data that reflect its status as a popular vacation destination and year-round community.

Demographics:

Martha’s Vineyard has a diverse and dynamic demographic landscape:

  1. Year-Round Residents: The island is home to a year-round population consisting of both native residents and individuals who have chosen to live on the island permanently. This population includes families, retirees, artists, and professionals.
  2. Seasonal Visitors: During the summer months, Martha’s Vineyard experiences a significant influx of seasonal visitors, including tourists and second-home owners. This seasonal population substantially increases the island’s overall demographic diversity.
  3. Cultural Diversity: The island boasts a rich cultural tapestry, with residents and visitors representing various racial and ethnic backgrounds. The African American community, historically centered in Oak Bluffs, remains an essential part of Martha’s Vineyard’s cultural heritage.
  4. Age Distribution: The population includes individuals of all age groups, from young families to retirees. The island’s schools serve year-round residents, while many seasonal visitors are families with children.

Economy:

Martha’s Vineyard’s economy is characterized by several key factors:

  1. Tourism: Tourism is the backbone of the island’s economy. During the summer, Martha’s Vineyard becomes a popular vacation destination, attracting tourists from across the United States and around the world. Tourism-related businesses, including restaurants, accommodations, and recreational activities, thrive during this period.
  2. Real Estate: The real estate market on the island is robust, with a significant market for vacation homes and rental properties. Property values, especially in sought-after areas like Edgartown and Chilmark, have risen over the years.
  3. Agriculture: Agriculture plays a role in the island’s economy, with several farms producing a variety of crops, including vegetables, fruits, and dairy products. Farmers’ markets and locally sourced foods are popular among residents and visitors.
  4. Small Businesses: Local businesses, including boutiques, art galleries, and specialty shops, contribute to the island’s economy. Many of these businesses are locally owned and operated, adding to the island’s unique character.

Census Data:

As of 2023, the census data for Martha’s Vineyard reveal important insights:

  1. Population Growth: The population of Martha’s Vineyard experiences fluctuations throughout the year, with a significant increase during the summer months. Accurate year-round population figures are essential for local governance and services.
  2. Income Disparity: While the island attracts affluent seasonal residents, it also faces issues related to income disparity. Affordable housing remains a concern for both year-round residents and seasonal workers.
  3. Education: Martha’s Vineyard is served by several public schools that cater to the year-round population. The quality of education and access to educational resources are significant aspects of the community.
  4. Community Engagement: The census data may reflect community engagement, including volunteerism, cultural events, and civic participation, which contribute to the island’s vibrant social life.

In conclusion, Martha’s Vineyard in 2023 is characterized by its diverse demographics, tourism-driven economy, and unique census data that capture the ebb and flow of residents and visitors throughout the year. The island’s ongoing challenges include addressing affordable housing and maintaining its cultural heritage while adapting to changing demographics and economic trends.